The Dream of Dairy Farming is Alive in Danville

The new Car­son Fam­i­ly Farm is up and running

By Sharon Lakey
Twen­ty-five-year-old Casey Car­son leaned for­ward in the chair, his eyes lit with deter­mi­na­tion. “I don’t con­sid­er it a risk. I went into this with the atti­tude that it is going to work.”
Strik­ing out on his own as a dairy farmer in tough eco­nom­ic times is dar­ing in anyone’s book. It is also a hope­ful sign that dreams still flour­ish in an indus­try that has been in decline in our state for a long time now. Present­ly, only nine Danville farms are ship­ping milk; the Car­son Fam­i­ly Farm, the newest, began ship­ping to Hori­zon Organ­ic in March.
Dreams take a lot of work and sup­port from many cor­ners to become a real­i­ty. For Casey, the idea gen­er­at­ed from a love of place. Many Danville res­i­dents may remem­ber him from his youth; he and his broth­ers, Brett and Asa, were those hand­some boys dri­ving a pair of young oxen in Danville Fair parades. The Car­son land lies between the vil­lages of Danville and North Danville. Beau­ti­ful rolling acres spread out on both sides of the road, and the state­ly Kit­tredge Hills stand guard in the distance.
Grand­par­ents Leonard and Hele­na lived just down the road from Par­tridge Lane where the boys grew up under the watch­ful eye of Janet, their moth­er. Though they nev­er milked, they raised beef, and the whole fam­i­ly got togeth­er in sum­mers to do the hay­ing. This effort kept 114 acres of Car­son land free of forest.
After grad­u­at­ing from Danville High School in 2002, Casey found work milk­ing at two local dairies: the Web­ster farm in Danville and the Kemp­ton farm in Peacham. In the fall, he entered Ver­mont Tech­ni­cal Col­lege to study dairy, but it was always a “hands-on” edu­ca­tion that com­pelled Casey. He sought and land­ed a job at Sprague’s Dairy Farm in Brook­field, VT, an oper­a­tion milk­ing 400 head, three times a day. “I was spend­ing a lot more time out there than in class,” Casey admits. He quick­ly decid­ed col­lege wasn’t for him.
In the back of his mind was a burn­ing ques­tion, one that was put to him by two old­er men­tors when he was hir­ing out as a milk­er. Don Moore of Peacham and Matthew Lind­strom of Molly’s Pond asked him, “What are your long term plans? Where are you going from here?”
Hop­ing to answer that ques­tion, he decid­ed to try his hand at milk­ing on his own. He rent­ed a farm in 2005 from Melvin Churchill in Cabot. Find­ing the barn too small, he looked for a larg­er space and moved his cows to an emp­ty barn owned by Bet­ty and Albert Ack­er­man, where he milked through the win­ter of 2007. But when the Ack­er­man grand­chil­dren decid­ed they want­ed to milk, he was out of a barn and end­ed up sell­ing his herd to them.
With­out a barn, what was he to do? “My Grand­fa­ther and Mom were very sup­port­ive,” says Casey, and the thought of plac­ing a new barn on Car­son land took hold. When he expressed self-doubt, he remem­bers his mom’s reflec­tive words, “Mon­ey wor­ries every­one.” Fel­low Danville dairy­man, Everett McReynold’s encour­aged him as well, and Casey came up with a plan. The Ver­mont Eco­nom­ic Devel­op­ment Author­i­ty (VEDA) thought the plan sound and fam­i­ly sup­port wor­thy, because they offered him loans to build the barn and start oper­a­tions. “They’re work­ing with me,” said Casey, who will begin to pay back the loan this fall.
Those dri­ving the road between North Danville and Danville last sum­mer saw the dream-barn emerge, stick by stick. With added mus­cle from Jesse Kit­tredge, Geoff Pel­leti­er and Ryan Ward, who helped set the posts and car­ry­ing beam, the big barn grad­u­al­ly appeared. It’s locat­ed in the field just behind his boy­hood home, set at an artis­tic angle to the road and paint­ed red. The free stall design was cho­sen for the con­ve­nience of a one-per­son milk­ing oper­a­tion. “I think it’s bet­ter for the cows, too,” said Casey, “because they can walk around.” The design also allows for lots of air­flow, keep­ing the barn fresh dur­ing Vermont’s long winters.
Leonard got to see the barn, but didn’t get to see it in action. “It real­ly hurt me when he died; he was a big sup­port for me,” said Casey of his death in ear­ly Jan­u­ary. In spir­it he is there, though, in the form of a por­trait hang­ing in the tank room and his red trac­tor sit­ting beside the barn along with Casey’s yel­low Cater­pil­lar Chal­lenger. The skid steer, used to clean the barn, is yet to arrive.
Casey decid­ed to go organ­ic because of the size of his farm and a high­er price for the prod­uct. He likes the man­age­ment style that comes with organ­ic, too, because the cows must be able to pas­ture. To accom­mo­date their range, he will work to clear more of the pas­tures that have grown up. Grain is pur­chased from Mor­ri­son Cus­tom Feeds in Bar­net, who han­dle organ­ic feeds in the area. “I trust them,” he says. Field­work is hired out to Matt Gilman of Wheelock.
His favorite cows are a cross between Hol­stein and Jer­sey. “Hol­stein for the pro­duc­tion and Jer­sey for the milk qual­i­ty,” said Casey. He pur­chased young cows that had nev­er been milked this spring from John and Bev­er­ly Rut­ter, who were down­siz­ing their herd. The bank con­sid­ers a cow viable for three to four years, but “they can go longer if organ­ic, because you aren’t push­ing pro­duc­tion so hard,” said Casey. For the next few years, he plans to milk around 60, but his even­tu­al goal is to milk 80, a fig­ure he feels is eco­nom­i­cal­ly sound and match­es the size of his barn and acreage.
Though there is no set sched­ule, a typ­i­cal day for Casey might go like this:
5:00: up for morn­ing milk­ing (1 ½ hour job)
7:30–8:00 feed the cows
Break: nev­er set, but some­time between 8:00 and 9:00
Fenc­ing and odd jobs
12:00: lunch
More work around the farm
4:30: get ready to milk
5:00: evening milking
7:00 to 7:30: finished
On the day of this inter­view, Casey was hard at work with a very impor­tant partner—two-year-old Tay­lor, his daugh­ter. It was the evening milk­ing time, 4:30 in the after­noon on a cold April day. “She loves the barn,” said Casey, and it was appar­ent from every­thing she did. The child was in per­pet­u­al motion. First, she used her lit­tle pink shov­el, then loaded a buck­et for feed­ing the calf, then prac­ticed using the cups for the milk­ing appa­ra­tus, then moved a few cow piles from one place to anoth­er with a hoe in the unused side of the milk par­lor. Final­ly, she asked her dad if she could lie down, and he escort­ed her into the front room where there was a couch for Taylor’s well-deserved nap.
“It only takes about an hour and a half to milk now,” said Casey, mov­ing eas­i­ly from one cow to the next in the milk­ing par­lor. Per­haps all those hours work­ing the oxen as a kid helped, because every­thing went smooth­ly for the young cows. Two were con­fused when enter­ing the par­lor, but in short order Casey was able to talk them through it with­out rais­ing his voice. “I used to yell a lot, but yelling doesn’t real­ly get you any­where,” he said.
What kind of per­son does it take to dairy? “It’s hard to tell,” said Casey. “You have to like to work, espe­cial­ly out­side. You nev­er know what’s going to hap­pen, and there’s always some­thing to do. It takes the right kind of per­son to want to dairy.”
To view oth­er pho­tos relat­ed to this arti­cle, click here.
This arti­cle was first pub­lished in June issue of The North Star Month­ly.
Share